Movie-based video games rarely get high ratings. They might sell well, but for the semi-hardcore gamer, it isn't even worth renting these half-finished games. But why can't a game developer create a successful movie-based game? I mean the content is there. You have some great storylines with characters already fleshed out. You have some excellent action-packed movies already released like The Dark Knight, Transformers, Wanted and James Bond's Quantum of Solace. So what gives? I'll tell you what gives; time.
Yes time. There is just not enough time to develop a decent video game when a movie is announced. On top of that, movie makers want a video game that doesn't stray too far from the theme of the movie, which puts game developers in a bind when they feel they have a great idea but the movie dudes disagree with them. So with the amount of time a game dev have plus trying to please the movie guys creates a horrible video game.
Want to know how bad some movie games are? Here are a list of low rates movie-based video games. All of these games scored below a 69 out of 100(or 6.9 out of 10) on metacritic.com:
- Jumper: Griffin's Story 2.9
- The Golden Compass 4.1
- Tron 4.3
- Hellboy: The Science of Evil 4.4
- Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer 4.5
- Iron Man 4.5
- Eragon 4.8
- Shrek-N-Roll 4.9
- WALL-E 5.0
- Beowulf 5.1
- Superman Returns: The Videogame 5.1
- X-Men: The Official Game 5.2
- Transformers: The Game 5.2
- Avatar: The Last Airbender - The Burning Earth 5.4
- The Incredible Hulk 5.5
- Shrek the Third 5.6
- Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian 5.6
- Ratatouille 5.6
- Lord of the Rings: Conquest 5.6
- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 5.8
- Cars Mater-National 5.8
- Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End 5.8
- Open Season 5.9
- The Spiderwick Chronicles 5.9
- Watchmen: The End is Nigh 6.1
- Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa 6.2
- Spider-Man 3 6.3
- Cars 6.5
- Meet the Robinsons 6.5
- Quantum of Solace 6.5
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix 6.8
Will movie-based games ever wow us? So far the highest rated movie-based game is Peter Jackson's King Kong with a score of 8.0 out of 10. This year, X-Men Origins: Wolverine, Wanted: Weapons of Fate, Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, and G.I. Joe are some of the few movies with games following with them. I hope they have ample time to finally prove us gamers wrong about the hopelessness of actually getting a worthy movie game title.
Head over to Jaquemini.com to read my guest post about video-game-based movies like Max Payne and why they fail so often.