If you read my article about the success of video games and movies in this recession, you would think that if these two were married they would make the perfect couple. However, history suggests this to be the opposite, as movie-based video games rarely get high ratings. They might sell well, but for the semi-hardcore gamer, it isn't even worth renting these half-finished games. But why can't a game developer create a successful movie-based game? I mean the content is there. You have some great storylines with characters already fleshed out. You have some excellent action-packed movies already released like The Dark Knight, Transformers, Wanted and James Bond's Quantum of Solace. So what gives? I'll tell you what gives; time.
Yes time. There is just not enough time to develop a decent video game when a movie is announced. On top of that, movie makers want a video game that doesn't stray too far from the theme of the movie, which puts game developers in a bind when they feel they have a great idea but the movie dudes disagree with them. So with the amount of time a game dev have plus trying to please the movie guys creates a horrible video game.
Want to know how bad some movie games are? Here are a list of low rates movie-based video games. All of these games scored below a 69 out of 100(or 6.9 out of 10) on metacritic.com:
- Jumper: Griffin's Story 2.9
- The Golden Compass 4.1
- Tron 4.3
- Hellboy: The Science of Evil 4.4
- Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer 4.5
- Iron Man 4.5
- Eragon 4.8
- Shrek-N-Roll 4.9
- WALL-E 5.0
- Beowulf 5.1
- Superman Returns: The Videogame 5.1
- X-Men: The Official Game 5.2
- Transformers: The Game 5.2
- Avatar: The Last Airbender - The Burning Earth 5.4
- The Incredible Hulk 5.5
- Shrek the Third 5.6
- Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian 5.6
- Ratatouille 5.6
- Lord of the Rings: Conquest 5.6
- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 5.8
- Cars Mater-National 5.8
- Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End 5.8
- Open Season 5.9
- The Spiderwick Chronicles 5.9
- Watchmen: The End is Nigh 6.1
- Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa 6.2
- Spider-Man 3 6.3
- Cars 6.5
- Meet the Robinsons 6.5
- Quantum of Solace 6.5
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix 6.8
Will movie-based games ever wow us? So far the highest rated movie-based game is Peter Jackson's King Kong with a score of 8.0 out of 10. This year, X-Men Origins: Wolverine, Wanted: Weapons of Fate, Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, and G.I. Joe are some of the few movies with games following with them. I hope they have ample time to finally prove us gamers wrong about the hopelessness of actually getting a worthy movie game title.
Head over to Jaquemini.com to read my guest post about video-game-based movies like Max Payne and why they fail so often.